
One early-game location where they can be found is the fence at Emerald Ranch. Some of these arrows are locked and their recipes have to be purchased. To complete challenge four, the player will have to craft a fire arrow, a dynamite arrow, an improved arrow, a small game arrow, and a poison arrow. One good option is to try to kill birds as they can often be found in groups and are usually killed in one shot. It is recommended to try and kill weaker animals for this challenge as the varmint rifle is not very powerful. A varmint rifle can be purchased in Valentine along with the ammo that it needs. The third challenge is to kill five animals using a varmint rifle. Many fish in the game can be kept in a player's inventory meaning that this challenge could potentially be completed in one trip. The easiest way to complete this is to turn in fish rather than bigger game.

The second challenge is to give five animal carcasses to the camp or a trapper.

The easiest way to attract the bluegills is to use cheese as bait. These fish can be found throughout the map and are one of the most common fish in the game. The first challenge in this series is a fairly easy one as the player only has to catch three bluegill fish.
